Psychologically intimidating questions
This study involved eighty eminent scholars in assessing the facts, theories, and methods of psychology.In 1983, the results were published in a seven-volume series entitled Psychology: A Study of Science.
It examines each theory with rigorous tests to see if it describes reality.The third major myth is that people who are experiencing mental-emotional behavioral problems are mentally ill.They are supposedly psychologically sick and, therefore, need psychological therapy.The common argument is that the doctor treats the body, the minister treats the spirit, and the psychologist treats the mind and emotions.Ministers, unless they are trained in psychoanalysis and psychotherapy, are then supposedly unqualified to help people who are suffering from serious problems of living.However, from a strictly scientific point of view, they have not been able to meet the requirements of true science.
In attempting to evaluate the status of psychology, the American Psychological Association appointed Sigmund Koch to plan and direct a study which was subsidized by the National Science Foundation.
The fourth major myth is that psychotherapy has a high record of success -- that professional psychological counseling produces greater results than other forms of help, such as self-help or that provided by family, friends, or pastors.
Thus, psychological counseling is seen as more effective than Biblical counseling in helping some Christians.
We will see, therefore, that psychoanalysis and psychotherapy have no compatibility with the Christian faith.
FOUR MYTHS ABOUT PSYCHOLOGY Among professing Christians, there are four major myths about psychology which have become entrenched in the Church: The first major myth is common to Christians and non-Christians alike: that psychotherapy (psychological counseling along with its theories and techniques) is a science -- a means of understanding and helping humanity based on empirical evidence gleaned from measurable and consistent data.
Koch describes the delusion in thinking of psychology as a science: "The hope of a psychological science became indistinguishable from the fact of psychological science.