Psychologically intimidating questions
We will see, therefore, that psychoanalysis and psychotherapy have no compatibility with the Christian faith.FOUR MYTHS ABOUT PSYCHOLOGY Among professing Christians, there are four major myths about psychology which have become entrenched in the Church: The first major myth is common to Christians and non-Christians alike: that psychotherapy (psychological counseling along with its theories and techniques) is a science -- a means of understanding and helping humanity based on empirical evidence gleaned from measurable and consistent data.
Now, when we speak of psychology as leaven we are not referring to the entire field of psychological study, such as valid research.Furthermore, Christians who are not even in the counseling ministry look to psychologists for advice on how to live, how to relate to others, and how to meet the challenges of life.In their attempts to be relevant, many preachers, teachers, counselors, and writers promote a psychological perspective of life rather than a Biblical one.The second major myth is that the best kind of counseling utilizes both psychology and the Bible.Psychologists who also claim to be Christians generally claim that they are more qualified to help people understand themselves and change their behavior than are other Christians (including pastors and elders) who are not trained in psychology.This is one of the main reasons why so many professing Christians are training to become psychotherapists. Men and women of God seek wisdom and knowledge from both the revelation of Scripture and the physical world.
Paul contends that everyone is accountable before God because of the evidence that creation gives of His existence (Rom. Scientific study is a valid way of coming to an understanding of God's work, and can be very useful in many walks of life.
The scientific method works well in observing and recording physical data and in reaching conclusions which either confirm or nullify a theory.
During the mid-19th century, scholars (philosophers, really) desired to study human nature in the hope of applying the scientific method to observe, record, and treat human behavior.
However, from a strictly scientific point of view, they have not been able to meet the requirements of true science.
In attempting to evaluate the status of psychology, the American Psychological Association appointed Sigmund Koch to plan and direct a study which was subsidized by the National Science Foundation.
The fourth major myth is that psychotherapy has a high record of success -- that professional psychological counseling produces greater results than other forms of help, such as self-help or that provided by family, friends, or pastors.